Random Number Generator has spoken! The winner is...
Commenter #8 who is...holy cow, it's Teddy Started It! The gal who said "THAT CHICKENPANTS IS MINE!" very early on. Well, congratulations, missy!
Thank you for all the comments, everyone! And for helping me to hang in there for three whole years. ^-^ I wish I could send you all gifts!
Also, can I just say thank goodness for Random.org? Because how on earth could I choose? Yikes. Especially with Flickr friends upping the ante with photos like this:
You all amaze me constantly. Thank you!